News

Treasury CS Mbadi and Attorney General Oduor Found in Contempt of Court, Summoned for Sentencing in Nairobi

A court in Nairobi, Kenya, has found National Treasury Cabinet Secretary John Mbadi and Attorney General Dorcas Oduor in contempt of court, with the two senior officials now set to appear in court for sentencing. The ruling sets up an uncommon legal confrontation between the judiciary and the executive, with Cabinet-level figures facing punishment over disobedience of court orders.

The finding arises from the long-running court dispute over the gender composition of the Cabinet, a matter in which the Attorney General’s office has been locked in a continued fight against a judgment directing compliance with constitutional requirements on gender balance. Mbadi and Oduor were found to have failed to comply with the court’s directions flowing from that litigation.

The contempt determination represents a rare spectacle in Kenya’s public life, where serving members of the Cabinet and the government’s chief legal advisor are committed to appear for sentencing. Court-issued contempt findings against senior state officials have historically been infrequent, making the upcoming sentencing appearance an exceptional development in the relationship between the bench and the executive.

At the centre of the dispute is the gender composition of the Cabinet appointed by President William Ruto. Petitioners challenged the makeup of the Cabinet on grounds that it fell short of the constitutional principle on gender balance, and the courts ruled in their favour, directing the government to act. The Attorney General’s office has since renewed its fight against that ruling, contesting the judgment even as the question of compliance remained unresolved.

Kenya’s 2010 Constitution provides that not more than two-thirds of the members of elective or appointive bodies shall be of the same gender. The Cabinet, as an appointive body whose members are nominated by the President and vetted and approved by Parliament, has repeatedly been drawn into litigation testing whether that principle binds its composition.

The two-thirds gender principle has been one of the most protracted constitutional questions in Kenya since the 2010 Constitution took effect. Successive Parliaments have failed to enact legislation fully implementing the rule for elective offices, and the gap has repeatedly pushed the matter into courtrooms, where judges have been asked to determine how the principle applies and what remedies follow when it is not met.

Under Kenyan law, contempt of court is punishable by fines or imprisonment, and courts possess the power to sanction individuals who disobey judicial orders. Where state officials are concerned, judges have at times issued conditional orders, allowing room for compliance before punishment is imposed. The path that led to the present finding saw the court’s earlier directions go unimplemented, prompting the contempt proceedings that culminated in the ruling against Mbadi and Oduor.

Attorney General Oduor, whose office represents the government in court, has continued to challenge the judgment on Cabinet gender balance while the contempt question advanced. Her renewed fight against the ruling has run in parallel with the enforcement proceedings, leaving the government simultaneously contesting the underlying decision and answering for the failure to abide by it.

Treasury Cabinet Secretary Mbadi’s inclusion in the contempt finding places him alongside the Attorney General among the most senior officials in the country now committed for sentencing. The two are expected to appear in court, where the question of the penalty to be imposed will be determined.

The sentencing appearance will be closely watched given the stature of the officials involved and the constitutional questions at the heart of the matter. Ahead of the court date, the government retains the option of moving to comply with the underlying orders, a step that has historically weighed on how courts approach punishment in contempt matters.

The Attorney General’s separate challenge to the ruling on Cabinet gender balance remains before the courts, even as Mbadi and Oduor prepare to answer for the contempt finding against them.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Related Articles

Back to top button